Colloquium: Miguel Ángel Sebastián (UNAM): Two Ways the Scientific Algebra Falls Short: What a Demon Still Doesn’t Know

When:
30 October, 2026 @ 11:30 am – 1:30 pm
2026-10-30T11:30:00+01:00
2026-10-30T13:30:00+01:00
Abstract:
 
Imagine a demon who knows everything statable in the vocabulary of science: every physical fact, every law, every causal and functional profile. It knows which world is actual. What could it still not know? 
I argue that it falls short in two different ways. The first is familiar from Lewis’s two gods: knowing which world is actual does not tell you your location inside it (who you are or your location in time or space). Here the scientific algebra is built on points (possible worlds) that are too coarse. 
The second concerns the phenomenology of an experience it has not had. On the view I defend, what the demon gains when it first sees red is not a new fact about the actual world but a new distinction. It grasps a transworld property: one that coincides with a physical property wherever physics is all there is, but sorts possible subjects that science cannot tell apart. Here the points are fine enough; the algebra over them is not. The view requires neither phenomenal fundamentals nor brute necessities. If this is right, physicalism about the actual world may be true, and science may settle every question about which world is actual, while ignorance about the phenomenal remains. What science leaves out, in both cases, is not a fact but a way of carving the space of possibilities.