Colloquium – Alba Montes Sánchez (Universidad Carlos III de Madrid): The affective ambivalence of migration privilege

When:
12 February, 2027 @ 11:30 am – 1:30 am
2027-02-12T11:30:00+01:00
2027-02-12T01:30:00+01:00

Abstract:

The notion of privilege has become increasingly prevalent in recent analyses of the
marginalization of oppressed minorities. Activists urge increasing number of groups to
“check their privilege” (e.g. racial or gender privilege) and take responsibility for what
they find. For a great number of people, this process can cause unpleasant emotions
such as discomfort, guilt or shame. Thus, philosophers are devoting more and more
attention to the phenomenology and moral psychology of discomfort in these morally-
laden contexts, and a debate has emerged on whether or not discomfort can be morally
productive and, if so, how best to harness it towards social justice.

In this talk, I focus on a case that is seldom discussed in the literature: discomfort about
migration privilege. My aim is to take the first steps towards an account of the moral
emotional landscape of this ambiguous form of privilege. In other words, I seek to map
and explore the consequences of the ambivalent feelings that migrants who relocate in
comparatively advantaged financial, legal or cultural conditions experience about their
situation. I do this based on the preliminary study of three vignettes from fieldwork
among intra-EU migrants, to show that discomfort about privilege can have, at least, two
opposing consequences. On the one hand, it has the counter-productive effect of
leading privileged migrants to trying to ignore and neglecting to address their own
suffering linked to migratory grief, for example. Nonetheless, on the other, it can
increase solidarity and encourage building bridges towards less privileged migrants to
improve everyone’s conditions.