Miguel Gramage – A Defense of a Usage-Based Account of Information (Colloquium)

When:
9 May, 2025 @ 11:30 am – 1:30 pm
2025-05-09T11:30:00+02:00
2025-05-09T13:30:00+02:00

Miguel Gramage (University of Valencia): A Defense of a Usage-Based Account of Information

Abstract: In this talk, I will explore the relation between agency and information within the  ecological psychology framework. I will challenge the traditional view, which broadly holds that agency arises when an animal is faced with several possibilities for action (i.e., affordances) and thus must select which to act upon. This notion of selection follows from a conception of information—and thus of affordances—as existing independently of the animal’s current activities. On this view, information places the animal in perceptual contact with mere possibilities for action, from which it must select the relevant ones.
By contrast, I will argue that this conception does not underlie some of the more promising ecological accounts of agency. Specifically, I will focus on habit-based theories, as developed by authors such as Heras-Escribano (2021) or Segundo-Ortín (2022). I will suggest that their accounts implicitly rely on a usage-based conception of information (Oyama 2000; Withagen & van der Kamp 2010; van Dijk & Kiverstein 2021), one that is grounded in the practical engagements and intentional activities of the animal. From this perspective, ecological information does not bring us into contact with mere possibilities for action, but rather with those possibilities that are relevant for the ongoing activity. As a result, the notion of selection need not play a central role in our conceptualization of agency.