Joan Camarena (University of Valencia): Self-organization assessed. The rise of complexity in the world
Abstract: According to Boltzmann’s formulation of the second law of thermodynamics, the universe flows toward greater disorder or entropy. However, since the works of von Bertalanffy, Schrödinger, and Prigogine, among others, we know that life is a phenomenon that manifests in the cosmos in an ordered manner. How is it possible for something as ordered as life to emerge from disorder? Does the second law of thermodynamics apply to living systems? The idea is that living systems can be understood as complex, autocatalytic, and self-organized systems with replicating components that aim to escape from thermodynamic equilibrium by dissipating free energy from their surroundings. From this perspective, the concept of self-organization is framed in autocatalytic terms, describing a process where the organizational pattern emerges solely from the dynamic interactions among the components of the system (Camazine et al., 2001; Kauffman 1993, 2000, 2024).
My aim in this talk is to evaluate this conception of self-organization, demonstrating that it is unsatisfactory within an evolutionary theory of biological complex systems. To this end, I will address three objectives. First, I will redefine self-organization in terms of a principle of maximum entropy production, which posits that complex systems (both living and non-living) tend to evolve in complexity through configurations that maximize the rate of energy dissipation within the constraints imposed by both the environment and their internal structure (Kondepudi et al., 2015; Swenson, 2010). Second, I will define self-organization in living systems as an autocatakinetic process instead of an autocatalytic. That is, while non-living systems are “slaves” to their local potentials, living systems can seek, direct, and access nonlocal potentials in constituting their autocatakinetics (Swenson, 2020). Third, I will argue that while self-organization is relevant in certain contexts, it cannot serve as the sole explanation for the emergence of complex structures in nature. The complexity observed in biological systems requires not only explaining the spontaneous and self-organized emergence of patterns but also addressing the functional value of the resulting structures and processes. It is this functional value that selects and sustains complex forms throughout evolution.
