Abstract:
The main aim of this talk is to motivate the rejection of Relationalism, the most widely accepted analysis of propositional attitude attributions. According to Relationalism, (i) attitude verbs are two-place predicates, (ii) “that”-clauses are singular terms designating propositions, and (iii) attributions are used to describe facts consisting of subjects standing in relations to propositions. The rejection of Relationalism is usually motivated on the basis of Prior’s puzzle, which shows that it is not always possible to substitute a “that”-clause for another singular term designating the same proposition while preserving the truth-conditions. However, Prior’s puzzle does not seem to provide a good motivation for rejecting Relationalism, given that the puzzle does not arise with all propositional attitude verbs and that defenders of Relationalism have offered convincing solutions to it. As an alternative strategy, I will argue that Relationalism precludes a satisfactory solution to Frege’s puzzle—that is, the problem of why it is not always possible to substitute salva-veritate coextensional expressions within “that”-clauses. First, I will argue that Relationalism implies a particular explanation of why instances of Frege’s puzzle arise, namely that the speaker, the audience, and the subject of the attribution do not stand in the same epistemic relation to the relevant proposition or its constituents. Second, I will show that Fregeanism and Russellianism—the two main families of solutions to Frege’s puzzle—presuppose Relationalism and its way of understanding the puzzle. I will argue that, as a consequence, these approaches cannot account for cases in which the subject of the attribution knows that the substituted expressions are coextensional, such as circumstances in which evaluative expressions (e.g., slurs or deadnames) are substituted for their allegedly neutral counterparts. I propose to reject (i) and suggest a relativist alternative to Relationalism, on which attitude verbs are analyzed as circumstance-shifting operators.
